What's new
Anthro World Forum

This is an anthropology forum where we cover all sorts of topics and discussions. Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts. Register today to become a member!

muh "white" ...who do you consider white ?

Kurdquistador

Moderator
Staff member
there are so many topics about whiteness in various forums . some people are obsessed with the term . now let us talk about it here i mean why not ? it is interesting and i want to read opinions of others

me personally i consider these people white :

- all europeans

- most northern west asians (Armenians , Kurds , Georgians , Pontic Greeks , many north Iranians (but not all) and many Levantines (but not all) etc.)

- ashkenazi jews , sephardic jews , many mizrahi jews




not white :

SSA people

east eurasian people such as chinese , japanese etc.

most south asians

gypsies

oceanic people such as papuans , australian aborigines

many southern west asian people like many yemenis , omanis , many arabians

many north africans

native american people

some iranians and a good amount of levantines . those iranians who look south asian shifted and score elevated s.indian . and when it comes to levantines they can have ssa and they can look exotic especially south levantines
 

Ezio1

Well-known member
I can agree with a lot of your classifications. If you took the traditional clothing away from some of these groups, many people could easily pass as ordinary citizens in Mediterranean European countries. 😂

Personally, I would look at two main factors: broadly Caucasoid facial features and skin tones ranging from fair to light brown, (pale to bronze and olive complexions). Of course, there’s a lot of variation within every population, so there will always be individuals who don’t fit neatly into one category. Appearance can overlap quite a bit between Europeans and West Asians, especially around the Mediterranean.

As for Castizos, I think those who look predominantly Caucasoid or white could be considered white based on appearance alone in the United States. I’d put Castizos in a similar category to North Iranians and Levantines, where many, but certainly not all, could be considered white depending on their individual appearance.

Some castizos can look mostly Caucasoid but have a new world vibe, like a Mexican castizo have that Mexican look but have very Mediterranean facial features, those could be for debate were some consider them. Like Chicharito Hernandez. But I did say from light to light brown the darkest naturally, you can get darker by sun and still be white. But yea depends Who you ask i Guess.
IMG_9597.jpeg
 
Last edited:

Ezio1

Well-known member
I can agree with a lot of your classifications. If you took the traditional clothing away from some of these groups, many people could easily pass as ordinary citizens in Mediterranean European countries. 😂

Personally, I would look at two main factors: broadly Caucasoid facial features and skin tones ranging from fair to light brown, (pale to bronze and olive complexions). Of course, there’s a lot of variation within every population, so there will always be individuals who don’t fit neatly into one category. Appearance can overlap quite a bit between Europeans and West Asians, especially around the Mediterranean.

As for Castizos, I think those who look predominantly Caucasoid or white could be considered white based on appearance alone in the United States. I’d put Castizos in a similar category to North Iranians and Levantines, where many, but certainly not all, could be considered white depending on their individual appearance.

Some castizos can look mostly Caucasoid but have a new world vibe, like a Mexican castizo have that Mexican look but have very Mediterranean facial features, those could be for debate were some consider them. Like Chicharito Hernandez. But I did say from light to light brown the darkest naturally, you can get darker by sun and still be white. But yea depends Who you ask i Guess.
View attachment 24397
@Kurdquistador @idklolimo @Turkic Warrior
 

IberoTarasco

Moderator
Staff member
Country
United-States
Here in the United States, if you are genetically over 80% European you would be considered White, however among Castizos, the dark ones would be considered "Hispanic/Latino" while the light ones would be considered "White", its a bit similar for Quadroons, but they often come out more mixed looking than Castizos in general.

These Castizos would be seen as "White" here in the United States.
jX24emW1_400x400 (2).jpgFB_IMG_1794573039021.jpgFB_IMG_1794573063108.jpg

While these Castizos would be seen as "Hispanic/Latino".
FB_IMG_1794573110650.jpgFB_IMG_1794573081045.jpgFB_IMG_1794573147271.jpg
 

IberoTarasco

Moderator
Staff member
Country
United-States
As for MENA people's, these ones would be considered "White" here in the United States.
images (39).jpegSXSW_2016_-_Rami_Malek_25138464364_cropped-683x1024.jpg

While the newly elected US Senator from Michigan would be seen as "Middle Eastern".
AP26148711116190-1024x683.jpg

Also, keep in mind if you come from a Christian background you are more likely to be seen as "White", but if you come from a Muslim background you would be seen more as a "Middle Eastern".
 

Kurdquistador

Moderator
Staff member
i have met americans in real life . some of them saw me as white while others did not . and i have talked to several americans online and they said that in some states i would be seen as white while in others i would not
 

IberoTarasco

Moderator
Staff member
Country
United-States
i have met americans in real life . some of them saw me as white while others did not . and i have talked to several americans online and they said that in some states i would be seen as white while in others i would not
Honestly I met a few Caucasoid Americans that look like you, one dude who worked at the Airport in Burbank, one lawyer at Court, one psychiatrist, and one supposedly a Police Officer, I think could have been Lebanese, Armenian, Jewish, or maybe Greek.
 

Kurdquistador

Moderator
Staff member
Honestly I met a few Caucasoid Americans that look like you, one dude who worked at the Airport in Burbank, one lawyer at Court, one psychiatrist, and one supposedly a Police Officer, I think could have been Lebanese, Armenian, Jewish, or maybe Greek.

apperently i would be white in places like new york while not white in places like minnesota or something if i remember right



51268769nm.jpg





49892886ig.jpg





46394746qy.jpg




42340920tu.jpg




46108301op.png




46104197sc.jpg




35950390nx.jpg
 

IberoTarasco

Moderator
Staff member
Country
United-States
apperently i would be white in places like new york while not white in places like minnesota or something if i remember right



51268769nm.jpg





49892886ig.jpg





46394746qy.jpg




42340920tu.jpg




46108301op.png




46104197sc.jpg




35950390nx.jpg
Well, I haven't been to New York or Minnesota, I know that Minnesota has a significant population of people of Scandinavian, German, & Luxembourger ancestry, while New York is more mixed like the Italians, Jews, Greeks, Caribbean Criollos (mainly Cubans & Puerto Ricans), Dutch, Anglo/WASP, & Irish, especially in the NYC area.

Besides California, I've been to Brookings, Oregon (the first town just north of the California-Oregon border, two hours north of here up the 101), I've been to Brookings several times since 2016, and recently I spent a night in Chicago & briefly in Denver, earlier this year after returning from Europe with my wife, in California, Ive been all over, including LA, the Bay Area, the Central Valley, Santa Cruz, Ukiah, etc, I haven't visited some parts of California yet such as San Diego & the Sierra Nevada area east of Sacramento heading to Nevada, what I'll say here in California you would be seen as either "White" or "Middle Eastern".
 

Kurdquistador

Moderator
Staff member
Well, I haven't been to New York or Minnesota, I know that Minnesota has a significant population of people of Scandinavian, German, & Luxembourger ancestry, while New York is more mixed like the Italians, Jews, Greeks, Caribbean Criollos (mainly Cubans & Puerto Ricans), Dutch, Anglo/WASP, & Irish, especially in the NYC area.

Besides California, I've been to Brookings, Oregon (the first town just north of the California-Oregon border, two hours north of here up the 101), I've been to Brookings several times since 2016, and recently I spent a night in Chicago & briefly in Denver, earlier this year after returning from Europe with my wife, in California, Ive been all over, including LA, the Bay Area, the Central Valley, Santa Cruz, Ukiah, etc, I haven't visited some parts of California yet such as San Diego & the Sierra Nevada area east of Sacramento heading to Nevada, what I'll say here in California you would be seen as either "White" or "Middle Eastern".

well that is interesting and good to know but i personally i dont give much importance to how whiteness is viewed in usa (or anywhere else for that matter) . to me all racially caucasian people are white because just like how negroid = black , caucasian = white to me . by the way here in germany on the few times in my life where whiteness has been a topic i have been considered white by the germans and i also get mistaken for south european pretty often by them
 

IberoTarasco

Moderator
Staff member
Country
United-States
well that is interesting and good to know but i personally i dont give much importance to how whiteness is viewed in usa (or anywhere else for that matter) . to me all racially caucasian people are white because just like how negroid = black , caucasian = white to me . by the way here in germany on the few times in my life where whiteness has been a topic i have been considered white by the germans and i also get mistaken for south european pretty often by them
Honestly, Race is both genetic & socially constructed, here in America if you are mixed-race you are classified under your "darkest" race if you are Mulatto like Obama, you are Black, or if you are Eurasian or Hapa, you are Asian.

Obama for example would be classified as "Pardo" in Brazil, "Coloured" in South Africa, & "Mulatto" in Haiti, but here in the US, he considered black or mixed-race.

For Multi-Generational Mixed-race Latinos it a different story, because they don't have two parents of two different races, both of their parents are mixed, and likely they been mixed for at least a few generations, some being mixed for centuries, so here in America its always been hard to classify Latinos.

Race from a Genetic perspective, includes how two 100% White parents always have White children, two 100% Black parents always have black children, 100% Amerindian parents have Amerindian children, and 100% Asian parents always have Asian children, also commercial DNA tests like 23andMe can tell you your race, some racial or ethnic groups are more likely to have certain diseases, such as Tay-Sachs among Ashkenazi Jews & Sickle-Cell among Blacks, another example is alcohol consumption, Native Americans often react different to alcohol than Whites for example, also some medications are only for certain races, such as BiDil which is only for Blacks, on a more controversial debate, some have argued that different races are better at some sports than others, or that different races have different forms of intelligence or behaviors, but its very controversial to discuss that, especially with the current political climate, I would say that IQ tests can be wrong, as someone might be mentally Retarded on math, but very intelligent on science, also sleep & level of education plays a huge role on how the results of a IQ test will show.

Aside from the head (which includes facial features, type of hair, skull shape, type of teeth, and maybe ear size), the only thing visible that is associated with race below the head is your skin color, which is why skin color is often the most commonly associated trait with race, although some argue or have debated that some racial groups have different types of body fat.

But from a socially constructed view on race, I would say that mixed-race people are a very good example of how they are classified racially, for example I'm 65% European & 30% Amerindian, but when I picked up some legal charges years ago, they put me as "Hispanic" on the police reports, when I lost a friend to a restraining order, his lawyer put my race as "Hispanic" on the order, while when I went to jail, they asked me what race I was & I said "White, Hispanic, and Native American" and they said that I can only choose one, and I chose "White" which I sorta of regret, and my 2nd time in jail they put me as "White" again, if you look mixed, they often ask you what race you are during your time in county jail, some police officers from other cities in California have often left my race blank or put me as "other", in the hospital I was often put as "Other" on the hospital forms, with sometimes "Hispanic/Latino" as a race, in California, on the state level, Hispanic/Latino is considered a race, and on the federal level its considered an ethnicity, most of us are classified as "White" on a federal level, of course the census now allows self-identification and checking multiple racial categories, but I'm talking if you picked up a federal charge, even someone who is over 80% Amerindian from Oaxaca would be classified as "White" on a federal crime report, however the census plans to combine both the race and ethnicity categories into one category in 2030, with adding "MENA" as a ethno-racial category, and Hispanics/Latino being considered a ethno-racial category as well, while Spanish Peninsulares can still check both White & Hispanic/Latino and Indigenous Mexicans can check both American Indian & Hispanic/Latino.

My wife's father & stepfather are both immigrants from Canada, but because they are both 100% White & Native speakers of North American English, they never suffered the racial xenophobia that myself & most of my family have experienced.

Yes, I agree with you, I do prefer the anthropological & genetic definition of race, but in everyday practical terms outside of forums like here, the socially and legally constructed versions of race can be important too.
 
Top