What's new
Anthro World Forum

This is an anthropology forum where we cover all sorts of topics and discussions. Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts. Register today to become a member!

Which group in Italy Blends more With Italians? My Observations of Different Ethnic Groups in Italy 🇮🇹🤔

Which of these populations do you think could pass as Italian (especially Southern Italian and Sicil

  • Latinos

    Votes: 2 100.0%
  • Romaní Gypsies

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • West Asians- Turks, Kurds, Lebanese etc

    Votes: 2 100.0%
  • North Africans

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • South Asians - indians etc

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Total voters
    2

Ezio1

Well-known member
While traveling around Italy, I've been paying more attention to how people from different ethnic backgrounds look, and I've noticed some interesting overlaps and differences. These are just my personal observations from the people I've encountered, not scientific conclusions or rules about entire populations.

Latinos and Gypsies/Romani people: I've noticed that some Latinos and Romani people can look surprisingly similar to each other. In certain cases, I could imagine someone mistaking one for the other based on complexion, facial features, and overall appearance. Some Latinos I've seen look conventionally Southern European or Mediterranean at first glance, but smaller details, such as the eyes, nose, or body proportions, can give me a different impression.

One funny thing I noticed about some Romani people I saw on the streets was their long black hair, sometimes tied into a ponytail. It gave me a very La India María vibe 😂.
IMG_9568.jpeg

I even saw one woman who reminded me of her, except with a more Balkan Romanian Gypsy looking face. It was an unexpected combination that caught my attention!

South Asians: Of the groups I've encountered in Italy, South Asians have generally stood out to me the most visually. Many of the people I've seen have had darker complexions and combinations of facial features that look quite different from those of the average Italian I've encountered.

Personally, I generally wouldn't confuse the South Asians I've seen with Romani people. Even when some Romani individuals have darker complexions, their overall appearance can still strike me as having a stronger combination of European, West Asian, and South Asian-associated features. Romani populations have complex histories of migration and admixture, and genetic studies have found South Asian ancestry alongside West Eurasian ancestry. That historical background makes the comparison interesting, although individual appearance and DNA ancestry don't always correspond neatly. But it’s my observation that, I can tell who’s the gypsy vs South Asian immigrajt

North Africans and Afghans: North Africans have also stood out to me, although I've noticed some overlap with some Southern Europeans. But I would say they pass more as an Arab than Italianx The Italians I've encountered in Rome and Florence often looked relatively typical of the European appearance I associate with those areas. As I traveled farther south, I started noticing more of the Mediterranean looks I had expected to see in Italy. You start to see more Mediterranean looks with dinarization and some even look Armenoid influence, you can find somd off-European looks among South Italians but the typical still looks very South European overall.

In my experience, many Southern Italians I've encountered have olive complexions, with some lighter or light-brown skin tones. Some North Africans I've seen have darker olive or light-brown complexions.

Some Afghans I've encountered have facial features that remind me of other West Eurasian populations, some look similar to a South Asian too, but less dark, their complexions sometimes remind me of the North Africans I've seen. Afghanistan is also highly diverse, so I wouldn't expect everyone from there to look alike.

Middle Easterners and Jewish populations: This is where I find the overlap with Southern Europeans particularly interesting. Some Turks, Kurds, and Lebanese people can look quite similar to Southern Italians to me, both in facial features and complexion. There seems to be considerable overlap in the range of appearances I've encountered.

Jewish populations are diverse as well, ranging from individuals whose appearance I associate with the Mediterranean or Middle East to others who could be mistaken for Central or Northern Europeans. There isn't one single Jewish appearance, just as there isn't one single Southern European appearance.

As for Sub-Saharan Africans, I'll leave them out of this particular comparison 😂. My focus here is on the populations I've encountered whose appearances I find overlap more with Southern Europeans, including populations with varying degrees of West Eurasian ancestry.

Of course, these are personal impressions based on the people I've encountered in Italy. No population has one standard appearance, and you can't reliably determine someone's ancestry just by looking at them.

I'm curious to hear other people's experiences: If you've spent time in Italy or elsewhere in the Mediterranean, have you noticed similar overlaps between Latinos, Romani people, South Asians, North Africans, Afghans, and Middle Easterners? Which groups have stood out to you the most, and what specific features caught your attention? 🤔
 
Last edited:

Ezio1

Well-known member

My subjective tier list​

S tier — None

I wouldn't put any group in S tier because I didn't encounter a population that consistently looked indistinguishable from the local Italians across all three regions.

A tier — Turks, Kurds, and Lebanese

These would rank relatively high for me, particularly in Southern Italy. Some individuals I've seen from these populations have facial features and complexions that overlap considerably with Southern Italians.

B tier — Some Latinos and some Romani people

I'd put these together because I've encountered individuals from both groups whose overall appearance could plausibly be mistaken for someone from Southern Europe. This applies more to Latinos whose appearance I associate with European or Mediterranean ancestry and less with visible African ancestry. Romani people also vary considerably, and some have a combination of features that I associate with both European and West Asian populations.

C tier — North Africans

I'd place North Africans below the preceding groups overall, although there's substantial overlap. Some individuals could easily remind me of Latinos or Southern Europeans, while others have an appearance that stands out more to me.

D tier — South Asians

Of the groups I've encountered, South Asians have generally stood out to me the most. The combinations of complexion and facial features I've observed have usually looked more distinct from the Southern Italians around them.

These rankings are based on my personal impressions, not on a claim that everyone from one population looks a certain way. Individual variation is substantial, and ancestry alone doesn't determine someone's appearance.

What do you think? If you've spent time in Italy, particularly in both Northern/Central and Southern Italy, would you rank these populations differently? And did you notice the same regional differences in Italian appearances that I did? 🤔 I only saw some differences when entering south Italy. Rome to Florence very inform
 
Last edited:

Ezio1

Well-known member

My subjective tier list​

S tier — None

I wouldn't put any group in S tier because I didn't encounter a population that consistently looked indistinguishable from the local Italians across all three regions.

A tier — Turks, Kurds, and Lebanese

These would rank relatively high for me, particularly in Southern Italy. Some individuals I've seen from these populations have facial features and complexions that overlap considerably with Southern Italians.

B tier — Some Latinos and some Romani people

I'd put these together because I've encountered individuals from both groups whose overall appearance could plausibly be mistaken for someone from Southern Europe. This applies more to Latinos whose appearance I associate with European or Mediterranean ancestry and less with visible African ancestry. Romani people also vary considerably, and some have a combination of features that I associate with both European and West Asian populations.

C tier — North Africans

I'd place North Africans below the preceding groups overall, although there's substantial overlap. Some individuals could easily remind me of Latinos or Southern Europeans, while others have an appearance that stands out more to me.

D tier — South Asians

Of the groups I've encountered, South Asians have generally stood out to me the most. The combinations of complexion and facial features I've observed have usually looked more distinct from the Southern Italians around them.

These rankings are based on my personal impressions, not on a claim that everyone from one population looks a certain way. Individual variation is substantial, and ancestry alone doesn't determine someone's appearance.

What do you think? If you've spent time in Italy, particularly in both Northern/Central and Southern Italy, would you rank these populations differently? And did you notice the same regional differences in Italian appearances that I did? 🤔
My Ranking from more to least blend in Italy society/population.

Without counting the Africans/blacks
I think South Asians are the group that stands out the most hands down?
What yall think. I could say the same for Spain

But for Spain il place Latinos higher and say some could pass as Spanish and Gypsy mix 😅 some could pass of course as just Spanish.

Second place, Turks, Kurds, Lebanese. Reason Spain has less Dinarization types. They exist but less. But can still blend with the population.
Third North Africans can maybe pass as heavy Gypsy mix .

South Asians again stand out, they too dark on average and look to uniform.
 
Last edited:

Ezio1

Well-known member
I think respectfully South Italians look what their DNA says. People from Rome and Florence look more like French people than with South Italians. Just some observation i wanted to mention. Don’t get me wrong , South Italians overall still look Italian but with their own look also different from Italians from Rome for example. By that I mean Rome common phenotype = more Dinarid, even Norics you see, South Italy more Mediterranean types, you find Berid looking people, while not really In Rome and up.
 
Last edited:

Ezio1

Well-known member
I added a poll with a question related to the topic, so feel free to vote for whichever options you think fit! 😁👍
 
Top