Semitic(East mediterranean+southwest asia)

[Ben Dover]

They are closer to you kind (Jews/Assyrians), than let say Afghans to Western Iranics such as Kurds and Talysh.

You are saying that as if you were any more northern west asian than me..

 

[Ben Dover]

You also made a nonsense claim about geo jews in this thread and I didn't respond to it but I might as well say a few words about it now. You said that in yazidi weddings in tbilisi, yazidis have invited some geo jews and that they look strikingly different from them and more semitic/southern. This is complete bullshit since even according to vengeance geo jews have a decent overlap with georgians and armenians in terms of phenotype and frankly they pass better in georgia than yazidis

 

[Guti]

You are saying that as if you were any more northern west asian than me..

I don't know how much you are mixed. Many Jews in Georgia are mixed. Many of them are mixed with Armenians, Russians etc. According to you, you have only 25% Georgian/North Western Asian ancestry. You are claiming 75% of your ancestry to be Jewish and that means 75% South Western Asian.
so, 25% north western asian and 75% semitic/south western asian

I am 100% Kurdish. So, that makes me 100% North Western Asian.

 

[Tyaraya]

Iron Age people from Kurdistan are genetically much closer to me than to you. I have shown you the evidence. I am native, you are an immigrant.

Lol, you don't know what you are talking about. Georgians and Ezdis are brothers. Georgians have by far much more respect for Ezdis than for the Armenians. Nobody likes Armenians in the first place, but this discussion is not relevant for now.

Again, that is what you claim, but you have claimed many other false things.
You are in their country and don't even speak their language properly per you own say and claim that they adore you, Sounds like a one sided story to me, we need to hear that from ethnic Georgians.

 

[Ben Dover]

They are closer to your Semitic kind (Jews/Assyrians), than let say Afghans to Western Iranics such as Kurds and Talysh.

Cool story. So these yemenis are closer to jews(as if it was an actual ethnicity but in this case you probably meant geo jews) and even to me 3/4 geo jew 1/4 georgian than afghans are to you as a yazidi kurd. The sky is the limit for your delusional mind

 

[Guti]

You also made a nonsense claim about geo jews in this thread and I didn't respond to it but I might as well say a few words about it now. You said that in yazidi weddings in tbilisi, yazidis have invited some geo jews and that they look strikingly different from them and more semitic/southern. This is complete bullshit since even according to vengeance geo jews have a decent overlap with georgians and armenians in terms of phenotype and frankly they pass better in georgia than yazidis

Maybe you pass better among Georgians than Ezdi Kurds do. But you don't pass among my people at all. You don't look like Ezdi Kurds at all.

I didn't mention Georgians at all. Most Georgian Jews don’t look like Ezdi Kurds, this is what I am saying.

 

[Ben Dover]

I don't know how much you are mixed. Many Jews in Georgia are mixed. Many of them are mixed with Armenians, Russians etc. According to you, you have only 25% Georgian/North Western Asian ancestry. You are claiming 75% of your ancestry to be Jewish and that means 75% South Western Asian.
so, 25% north western asian and 75% semitic/south western asian

I am 100% Kurdish. So, that makes me 100% North Western Asian.

Purebred Geo Jews are 100% southern west asian.. lol

It's funny because I even posted a result of a purebred geo jew here and he scored more northern west asian components than you in total. You have one hell of a nerve to say the things you say

 

[Guti]

Again, that is what you claim, but you have claimed many other false things.
You are in their country and don't even speak their language properly per you own say and claim that they adore you, Sounds like a one sided story to me, we need to hear that from ethnic Georgians.

What the fuck are you talking abou? It is not what I do claim. It is a fact. Ancient DNA from Iron Age Kurdistan is showing that.

This is F38 Hasanlu DNA (Gedmatch kit number = M381564), 971 - 832 BC. :

Location of the Iron Age Aryan/proto-Kurdish Hasanlu samples.

 

[Ben Dover]

Maybe you pass better among Georgians than Ezdi Kurds do. But you don't pass among my people at all. You don't look like Ezdi Kurds at all.

I didn't mention Georgians at all. Most Georgian Jews don’t look like Ezdi Kurds, this is what I am saying.

I never claimed that they look like yazidis. What I am saying is that they aren't more exotic/semitic looking than yazidis on average

 

[Guti]

Purebred Geo Jews are 100% southern west asian.. lol

It's funny because I even posted a result of a purebred geo jew here and he scored more northern west asian components than you in total. You have one hell of a nerve to say the things you say

No way, Gedrosia/Iran_ChL ancestry is also a North Western Asian component, period!

And I do score by far more Gedrosia/Iran_ChL than any Georgian Jew

 

[Tyaraya]

What the fuck are you talking abou? It is not what I do claim. It is a fact. Ancient DNA from Iron Age Kurdistan is showing that.

This is F38 Hasanlu DNA (Gedmatch kit number = M381564), 971 - 832 BC. :

Location of the Iron Age Aryan/proto-Kurdish Hasanlu samples.

You can stick your results where the sun never shines. No matter how hard you try, you are not native to where you claim to be from.

 

[Ben Dover]

No way, Gedrosia/Iran_ChL ancestry is also a North Western Asian component, period!

And I do score by far more Gedrosia/Iran_ChL than any Georgian Jew

Yes. A yazidi Kurd will score more West Central Asian/Gedrosia than a geo jew but that wasn't the whole point. Gedrosia isn't the only northern west asia component.. if it's the only northern west asian component then that means that baloch/makrani and other south central asian people are the most northern west asian.

You forgot about CHG and geo jews score more CHG than yazidis.

 

[Guti]

I never claimed that they look like yazidis. What I am saying is that they aren't more exotic/semitic looking than yazidis on average

Ezdi Kurds don't look Semitic. We look by far more Western Iranic (closer to Talysh and Persians)

On the other side Georgian Jews look more Semitic.

Therefore Georgian Jews (at least most of them) would stick out in an Ezdi crowd. Georgian Jews don't look Western Iranic/Kurdish. It is not rocket science

 

[Tyaraya]

I never claimed that they look like yazidis. What I am saying is that they aren't more exotic/semitic looking than yazidis on average

Based on the photos that you had posted in the past, Georgian Jews don not look like Yezidis. Georgian Jews are much lighter and have more resemblance to the people from the Balkans.

 

[Guti]

You can stick your results where the sun never shines. No matter how hard you try, you are not native to where you claim to be from.

Just lol, disprove my claim with scientific facts, my Semitic Assyrian immigrant neighbour!

These results are not fabricated but based on science!

 

[Ben Dover]

Ezdi Kurds don't look Semitic. We look by far more Western Iranic (closer to Talysh and Persians)

On the other side Georgian Jews look more Semitic.

Therefore Georgian Jews (at least most of them) would stick out in an Ezdi crowd. Georgian Jews don't look Western Iranic/Kurdish. It is not rocket science

It's not a rocket science that geo jews look more armenian and georgian like than yazidi kurds either.

What are you talking about.. Geo jews aren't more semitic or more exotic looking than yazidis kurds on average. You don't know what you are talking about.

Vengeance is far better at taxonomy and shiet and he has also seen a lot of geo jew pics so maybe if he wishes he can also say a few words about this

 

[Guti]

Yes. A yazidi Kurd will score more West Central Asian/Gedrosia than a geo jew but that wasn't the whole point. Gedrosia isn't the only northern west asia component.. if it's the only northern west asian component then that means that baloch/makrani and other south central asian people are the most northern west asian.

You forgot about CHG and geo jews score more CHG than yazidis.

Ezdi Kurds have more 'CHG + Iran_ChL + West Central Asian/Gedrosia 'combined, than Georgian Jews. Georgians Jews would have more Natufian/Levantine/Semitic/South Western Asian ancestry.

Ezdi Kurds have LESS 'Natufian/Levantine/Semitic/South Western Asian' ancestry. And that's why Georgian Jews are less Northe Western Asian, while Ezdi Kurds are 100% North Western Asian.

 

[Kurdquistador]

guti classifies / passifies people mostly based on his opinions about those peoples and also with his biased "but they semitic language n shiet" thoughts and last but not least his personal agenda

dont take it seriously

 

[Tyaraya]

Just lol, disprove my claim with scientific facts, my Semitic Assyrian immigrant neighbour!

These results are not fabricated but based on science!

I am not your neighbor, Luckily I live at least 10,000 miles away from where you are. You stink up any neighborhood you move into.

 

[Ben Dover]

@Guti I remember you telling me that I easily pass as west iranic and you basically called vengeance a hypocrite and a liar when he said that I passed well in Cyprus because you know Cypriots are SW Asians and shiet..

Anyway, when you were less biased towards me you also said different things about my appearance